When Zdnet’s Ed Bott Gives a Bad Editorial, Who Pays?

Ed Bott from Zdnet recently wrote an article berating Microsoft Blogger Stephen Anacker for "Bad Advice" because a friend of Ed’s had a problem with the BETA version of Microsoft’s Internet Explorer 7 

Ed disingenuously states "Now, I really don’t mean to pick on the author of this post . . ." — but then proceeds to pick him apart! 

  • Ed is worried that Stephens’s readers won’t know about Registry “key names” or how to expand a registry tree — but for Stephen’s intended TECHNICAL audience this is all we need. The criticism that it’s not adequate for an amateur — is true, but misplaced.

  • Ed mentions that his friend needed to call HIM for help with his Internet Explorer 7 problem — yet Microsoft has Free Phone Support at 1-866-876-4926  (Maybe Ed thinks he’s more quailfied to support his friend than Microsoft).

  • Ed also argues that every blog article about registry changes, include a "Registry Editor" warning — well Ed, that’s not the way blogs work. There IS a "warning" (disclaimer) on the main blog page. There are NOT individual warnings on each blog entry.

  • Ed is also worried that the "average" user can locate this article on Google – and that "average" users should be able to follow ANY set of instructions – even if intended for a technical audience – and even if they don’t understand them!

  • Ed feels he must mention some minor typographical & editing problems in his article — hey, Ed if you can’t be right on the big facts – be petty!

  • Ed also felt it was necessary to write an article instead of actually posting a comment on Stephen’s blog. Guess Ed’s above participating in other people’s blogs!  

 

NOTE: A Beta version of software means it is still in testing — Microsoft and all companies warn that you should NEVER install Beta software on a production computer. Period. I have a test computer for this purpose – don’t you? 

 

OK, I feel better now (^_^)

About these ads

About blakehandler

BLAKE was a Microsoft MVP and award winning programmer with over 20+ years experience providing complete Windows and networking support for small to medium sized businesses. BLAKE is also Jazz Musician and Instructor for residential clients on the Los Angeles West Side.
This entry was posted in Opinion. Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s